- Green Rising
- Posts
- Africa’s big climate gamble worked, but not the way intended
Africa’s big climate gamble worked, but not the way intended
A year ago the continent proposed a green new deal to rich countries. Here is what happened next
Hello – like every year in mid-September, global leaders are assembling in New York for the UN general assembly.
Last year, the event was a showcase for Africa’s green economy. Political and business leaders from the continent tried to sell the global north on a climate pact.
Since then, Africa has given itself a successful kick in the right direction. The rest of the world? Not so much.
The $3 trillion needed for climate action in Africa by 2030 (see our image) have yet to be loaded onto the card.
⏳ Today’s reading time: 4 mins
1. 🚁 Heli view: The west’s worrying lack of interest in African climate action
Over the past year, Africa successfully embarked on a new climate trajectory.
But major planks of a winning approach are still missing, not least the money.
Common goals: The most notable change on the continent has been unity of purpose.
Climate action had long pitted hydrocarbon giants such as Nigeria and Angola against renewables pioneers such as Kenya and Ethiopia
Alignment: Last year, at the inaugural Africa Climate Summit, some of the most powerful countries still hovered on the sidelines.
South Africa appeared more intent on industrial progress than a green future.
Together with two other top African economies it initially declined to sign the Nairobi Declaration, which set out a common climate position.
And yet: Between the UN general assembly a year ago and the COP 28 summit in December, existing momentum turned into a joint agenda.
Leaders cast off what Kenyan President William Ruto called the “shackles of low ambition”.
The lever: A realisation that the green economy could be Africa’s new growth engine appears to have been a common motivator.
Even oil giant Nigeria no longer wanted to stand aside as clean-tech investments overtook many traditional sectors.
Green deals represent almost half of all venture capital on the continent now (see chart).
Clear ambitions: Change is evident not only from speeches but policy.
Numerous countries have improved regulations around carbon markets, the import of electric vehicles and the processing of minerals critical for battery production.
Attention: Climate action has become a dominant issue in African political discourse.
The volume of misinformation has dropped, thanks to growing public awareness.
Left-wing concerns about the “hyper-financialisation” and “McKinseyfication” of climate action, i.e. finding market solutions, have dwindled.
Underlying driver: Africa’s climate trajectory is helped by a narrative shift.
The continent’s leaders have dropped talk of “victimhood” and ended “blame games”.
The Nairobi Declaration presents Africa as a bold pioneer rather than a pitiful beggar.
New positioning: The pitch from African leaders to the global community is simple: Africa did not cause the climate crisis but it presents the best chance to end it.
Africa has plenty of the resources needed to affect change.
Investing in Africa’s economies is key to global climate action.
Win-win: A year ago, African leaders started offering rich countries an explicit deal to trade sustainability in the north for prosperity in the south.
They tried to convince the world that Africa can do heavy lifting on climate.
The argument: Africa has key "endowments" essential to global decarbonisation.
Unmatched renewable energy potential including solar and geothermal
A third of the resources such as minerals needed in green technologies
Vast forests that can act as carbon sinks if supported properly
In return: Climate action should be linked directly to better economic opportunities for Africa.
There would be new for-profit funding mechanisms to drive climate investment
And a transformation of how Africa raises money on global capital markets
With the aim of creating millions of new jobs for its young & growing workforce
Key idea: The global fight against climate change must be a growth engine in Africa.
It could create a green industrial revolution, building on innovation
Resulting in a multi-billion-dollar investment opportunities
Enabling the continent to leapfrog traditional high-carbon development models from Europe, America and Asia
Initial support: Western leaders last year welcomed Africa’s strategic gambit.
The EU president said, "We fully support financial institutions reform. It is time to move from words to actions."
The UN secretary-general called for, "An international financial system that is able to provide effective debt mechanisms, longer repayment terms, better borrowing terms."
But since: Western leaders have focused on Gaza, Ukraine, elections and their own interest rates.
Global perceptions haven’t yet shifted. The exception is Beijing.
Africa is far from the climate powerhouse its leaders envision.
Follow the money: European governments are making lots of relatively small investments that are extremely useful and welcome.
Multilateral institutions and philanthropic funders also pitch in.
But nothing on a scale that would shift the needle across the continent.
This still feels more like development aid than a commercial climate compact.
Stuck: Few of the sensible if ambitious reform proposals are on track to be implemented.
African borrowers still pay up to 6% more than others with a similar risk profile.
Sovereign debts are not paused or written off against green initiatives.
Few new finance mechanisms and tools are available for climate action.
Above all: The volume of capital needed in Africa is seemingly not available during hard times in the west.
This is not just an issue for Africa. Developing countries globally need $2.4 trillion per year to handle climate change. Current total aid is $200 billion.
Old reality: Sovereign debt crises remain a serious obstacle to a green transition.
Governments such as Kenya’s tried to take steps unpopular at home in the short term to stabilise finances and keep the door open for western loans.
But they were ultimately defeated by street protests (and their own greed).
The only good news: None of this has stopped individual sectors and businesses in the green economy from prospering (see our cheat sheet). Still, the global agenda is yet to change.